Review by Rocky Balboa
Bottom
line: A heartfelt Superman movie that plays to a broad
audience thanks to an emotionally troubled Man of
Steel.
The Superman who returns in "Superman Returns"
is a different Man of Steel than we are used to seeing.
In "Superman: The Movie," the film by director
Richard Donner in 1978, the late Christopher Reeve
rescued the iconic superhero from high camp with the
sincerity and warmth of his acting. His Superman was
a romantic charmer. Director Bryan Singer positions
this new film as a sequel to Donner's film, and his
Superman -- played with winning fortitude by newcomer
Brandon Routh -- is less a Man of Steel than a Man
of Heart.
While Routh is the same age as Reeve when he played
the role, Routh's Superman is older in spirit. His
Superman has known heartbreak and loss. He thinks
about his late father and must consider the possibility
that he might have a son. He even faces his own mortality.
In other words, Singer wants to put human emotions
into his alien superhero, and for the most part, he
succeeds.
Not that the other kind of Superman movie turns up
missing. The hero's rescues are spectacular thanks
to the marvels of digital effects. And its villain,
Lex Luthor, and Luthor's female companion, Kitty Kowalski
-- deliciously played by Kevin Spacey and Parker Posey
-- spice the film with extravagant comedy. So old
fans can rejoice even as this "Superman"
wins new fans from among those who normally don't
care about superheroes.
Singer and writers Michael Dougherty and Dan Harris
imagine that the superhero has vanished for five years.
During that time, he has searched the far reaches
of space for his home planet of Krypton and has determined
that, yes, it is a destroyed planet. Now, returning
to Earth, he discovers that absence has not made the
heart grow fonder.
His mom (Eva Marie Saint) is overjoyed to see him,
of course. But Lois Lane (Kate Bosworth) has won a
Pulitzer by penning a story, "Why the World Doesn't
Need Superman," and the world has more or less
forgotten its savior.
Superman in his Clark Kent guise gets his old job
back at the Daily Planet from editor Perry White (Frank
Langella). Day 1 on the job, Lois is in deadly peril
when a space shuttle launched from the back of a jet
fails to disengage and rockets into space with the
jet still attached and Lois onboard. Fighting through
fire and molten debris, Superman brings the disintegrating
plane in for a soft landing in a crowded baseball
stadium before he and Lois can lock eyes for the first
time in five years. Well, he certainly knows how to
get the girl's attention.
But Superman can't overcome the obstacles he faces
in the new realities in Lois' life: Not only is she
still angry at him for disappearing without a word,
but she has a son, Jason (Tristan Leabu), and a fiance,
Richard White (James Marsden), the editor's nephew.
Meanwhile, Lex, newly sprung from prison, plots to
use Superman's own "crystal technology,"
married to Superman's Achilles' heel, kryptonite,
in an ingenious scheme to ignite a new land mass in
the Atlantic that will swamp North America while creating
a gigantic real estate venture for him. These evil
machinations barely leave Superman and Lois much time
to reflect on their relationship. But clearly, Superman
must wonder who Jason's father is even as he adjusts
to a role reversal that sees Lois and her fiance coming
to his rescue! Times have indeed changed.
To underscore the link to Donner's film, designer
Guy Hendrix Dyas borrows here and there from John
Barry's original design elements, composer John Williams'
"Superman" theme is woven through the film,
and Singer incorporates footage of Marlon Brando as
Jor-El, Superman's long-dead father, into the early
segments. However, this Superman does represent a
new generation of flying. Superman doesn't so much
fly as float. He can levitate a few feet or thousands
of feet in the air. He's a Michael Jordan who never
comes down. His nighttime excursion with Lois in the
skies above Metropolis is reminiscent of the romantic
moonlit ride Reeve gave Margot Kidder, his Lois, a
ride that thrilled female viewers a generation ago.
This high-wire act would have gone for naught if
Routh had not so capably filled the Man of Steel's
costume. Like Reeve, he is just right physically,
looking at times like the old comic book drawings
of Superman. There is honesty in his acting where
the emotions that play across Superman/Clark Kent's
face and body come from deep within. Bosworth's Lois
is a torn woman, highly ambivalent over the return
of a man she has tried to hard to forget. And young
Leabu does a nice job in conveying the innocence and
curiosity of a boy with a new hero/authority figure
in his life.
The oh-wow technical wizardry behind "Superman
Returns" accomplishes two things: It makes you
appreciate the huge advances in visual effects since
1978 but also appreciate the considerable accomplishments
of Donner's team back in the day.